Rex v Rose
| Jurisdiction | South Africa |
| Judge | Curlewis CJ, Beyers JA, De Wet JA and Watermeyer AJA |
| Judgment Date | 28 September 1937 |
| Court | Appellate Division |
-
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
View this document and try vLex for 7 days - TRY VLEX
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
122 practice notes
-
S v Rudman and Another; S v Mthwana
...the actual provisions of the law; we have to administer "justice" in accordance with the law; we have no choice.' It was said in R v Rose 1937 AD 467 at 'Now the term justice is not limited in meaning to the notion of retribution for the wrongdoer; it also connotes that the wrongdoer should......
-
S v Safatsa and Others
...Tranter v Attorney-General and Another 1907 TS 415 at 422 - 3; R v Du Plessis 1924 TPD 103 at 124; R v Mokoena 1932 OPD 79 at 80; R v Rose 1937 AD 467; R v Difford 1937 AD 370 at 373; R v Cohen 1942 TPD 266 at 272; R v Steyn 1954 (1) SA 324 (A) at 335D; R v H Cele 1958 (1) SA 144 (N) at 153......
-
S v Kruger en Andere
...1970 (1) PH H12 (A); S v Heller 1971 (2) SA 29 (A) op 53C; R v Foord 1948 (3) SA 507 (A) op 511; R v Burwood 1941 AD 217 op 227; R v Rose 1937 AD 467; R v Johnson 1939 AD 241; S v Grobler 1966 (1) SA 507 (A) op 513F - G; S v Verwey 1968 (4) SA 682 (A) I op 687H - 688A; R v Smit and Another ......
-
S v Rudman and Another; S v Mthwana
...the actual provisions of the law; we have to administer "justice" in accordance with the law; we have no choice.' It was said in R v Rose 1937 AD 467 at 476-7: 'Now the term justice is not limited in meaning to the notion of I retribution for the wrongdoer; it also connotes that the wrongdo......
Request a trial to view additional results
121 cases
-
S v Rudman and Another; S v Mthwana
...the actual provisions of the law; we have to administer "justice" in accordance with the law; we have no choice.' It was said in R v Rose 1937 AD 467 at 'Now the term justice is not limited in meaning to the notion of retribution for the wrongdoer; it also connotes that the wrongdoer should......
-
S v Rudman and Another; S v Mthwana
...the actual provisions of the law; we have to administer "justice" in accordance with the law; we have no choice.' It was said in R v Rose 1937 AD 467 at 476-7: 'Now the term justice is not limited in meaning to the notion of I retribution for the wrongdoer; it also connotes that the wrongdo......
-
S v Kruger en Andere
...1970 (1) PH H12 (A); S v Heller 1971 (2) SA 29 (A) op 53C; R v Foord 1948 (3) SA 507 (A) op 511; R v Burwood 1941 AD 217 op 227; R v Rose 1937 AD 467; R v Johnson 1939 AD 241; S v Grobler 1966 (1) SA 507 (A) op 513F - G; S v Verwey 1968 (4) SA 682 (A) I op 687H - 688A; R v Smit and Another ......
-
S v Safatsa and Others
...Tranter v Attorney-General and Another 1907 TS 415 at 422 - 3; R v Du Plessis 1924 TPD 103 at 124; R v Mokoena 1932 OPD 79 at 80; R v Rose 1937 AD 467; R v Difford 1937 AD 370 at 373; R v Cohen 1942 TPD 266 at 272; R v Steyn 1954 (1) SA 324 (A) at 335D; R v H Cele 1958 (1) SA 144 (N) at 153......
Request a trial to view additional results
1 books & journal articles
-
Recent Case: Criminal procedure
...of justice if it cannot hold that a reasonable trial court would inevitably have convicted if there had been no irregularity (R v Rose 1937 AD 467 at 476-7). This means that an irregularity will not be taken into account if it does not influence the final decision of the court. Conversely a......