S v Masingili and Others
Jurisdiction | South Africa |
Judge | Blignault J and Van staden AJ |
Judgment Date | 20 March 2013 |
Docket Number | A 448/12 |
Hearing Date | 20 March 2013 |
Counsel | A Pareis for the first appellant. Y Rajap for the second to fourth appellants. J de V van Niekerk (with A du Toit) for the appellants at the request of the court. A de V La Grange (with TS Sidaki) for the Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development. M Daliwe for the state. |
Court | Western Cape High Court, Cape Town |
-
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
View this document and try vLex for 7 days - TRY VLEX
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
7 practice notes
-
2014 index
...ZAECGHC 17 (15 April 2014 ..................................................................................... 236S v Masingili 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC) ............................................... 189-91S v Maswetswa 2014 (1) SACR 288 (GSJ) ............................................ 10......
-
S v Mofokeng
...In considering the merits of the appeal, the court felt obliged to consider the effect of the judgment in S v Masingili and Others 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC), and whether as a result of this decision the exact role of each of the accused persons in the commission of the robbery needed to be det......
-
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and Another v Masingili and Another
...2000 (1) SACR 414 (CC) (2000 (3) SA 1; 2000 (5) BCLR 491; [2000] ZACC 5): dictum in para [100] applied S v Masingili and Others 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC) ([2013] ZAWCHC 59): overturned on appeal G S v Mokela 2012 (1) SACR 431 (SCA) ([2011] ZASCA 166): referred to S v Moloto 1982 (1) SA 844 (A)......
-
S v Mofokeng
...at 202 – 203. See also S v Sesetse en 'n Ander 1981 (3) SA 353 (A) at 369 – 370; S v Mtsweni 1985 (1) SA 590 (A) at 593 – 594. [11] 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC). [12] Paragraph 20 of the [13] Paragraphs 21 – 27 of the judgment. [14] It is dubious whether any incident of robbery can, with any meas......
Request a trial to view additional results
6 cases
-
S v Mofokeng
...In considering the merits of the appeal, the court felt obliged to consider the effect of the judgment in S v Masingili and Others 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC), and whether as a result of this decision the exact role of each of the accused persons in the commission of the robbery needed to be det......
-
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and Another v Masingili and Another
...2000 (1) SACR 414 (CC) (2000 (3) SA 1; 2000 (5) BCLR 491; [2000] ZACC 5): dictum in para [100] applied S v Masingili and Others 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC) ([2013] ZAWCHC 59): overturned on appeal G S v Mokela 2012 (1) SACR 431 (SCA) ([2011] ZASCA 166): referred to S v Moloto 1982 (1) SA 844 (A)......
-
S v Mofokeng
...at 202 – 203. See also S v Sesetse en 'n Ander 1981 (3) SA 353 (A) at 369 – 370; S v Mtsweni 1985 (1) SA 590 (A) at 593 – 594. [11] 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC). [12] Paragraph 20 of the [13] Paragraphs 21 – 27 of the judgment. [14] It is dubious whether any incident of robbery can, with any meas......
-
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and Another v Masingili and Another
...C Order [61] The following order is made: 1. The order made by the Western Cape High Court, Cape Town, D in S v Masingili and Others 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC) ([2013] ZAWCHC 59), declaring s 1(1)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 to be constitutionally invalid, is not 2. The appeal b......
Request a trial to view additional results
1 books & journal articles
-
2014 index
...ZAECGHC 17 (15 April 2014 ..................................................................................... 236S v Masingili 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC) ............................................... 189-91S v Maswetswa 2014 (1) SACR 288 (GSJ) ............................................ 10......
7 provisions
-
2014 index
...ZAECGHC 17 (15 April 2014 ..................................................................................... 236S v Masingili 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC) ............................................... 189-91S v Maswetswa 2014 (1) SACR 288 (GSJ) ............................................ 10......
-
S v Mofokeng
...In considering the merits of the appeal, the court felt obliged to consider the effect of the judgment in S v Masingili and Others 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC), and whether as a result of this decision the exact role of each of the accused persons in the commission of the robbery needed to be det......
-
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and Another v Masingili and Another
...2000 (1) SACR 414 (CC) (2000 (3) SA 1; 2000 (5) BCLR 491; [2000] ZACC 5): dictum in para [100] applied S v Masingili and Others 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC) ([2013] ZAWCHC 59): overturned on appeal G S v Mokela 2012 (1) SACR 431 (SCA) ([2011] ZASCA 166): referred to S v Moloto 1982 (1) SA 844 (A)......
-
S v Mofokeng
...at 202 – 203. See also S v Sesetse en 'n Ander 1981 (3) SA 353 (A) at 369 – 370; S v Mtsweni 1985 (1) SA 590 (A) at 593 – 594. [11] 2013 (2) SACR 67 (WCC). [12] Paragraph 20 of the [13] Paragraphs 21 – 27 of the judgment. [14] It is dubious whether any incident of robbery can, with any meas......
Request a trial to view additional results