Labour on Meyersdal Structural Collapse Incident Inquiry

"Silence of the lambs” as the Department of Labour-instituted Meyersdal Inquiry comes to a premature end

Taking a cue from the contractor of the Meyersdal Eco Estate house that collapsed in Alberton who refused to answer questions yesterday, an engineer/designer who designed the house Ranjan Galal today, October 30 also refused to answer questions posed to him during the inquiry saying he “reserve the right to remain silent and not incriminate himself”.

Galal’s lawyer, Robert Krombein from NRFSA Attorneys said his client had not received engineering reports and this was substantially and procedurally unfair to his client, therefore “my client has right to remain silent when asked questions”.

Meyersdal Structural Incident Inquiry Presiding Officer, Phumudzo Maphaha cautioned witnesses against remaining silent saying: “the right to remain silent has limitations. I will hate to evoke my right as a commissioner to force out information that we require as a Commission. If we are unable to get information, this will render the inquiry useless.

“It looks like the tail is beginning to wag the dog, when the dog supposed to wag the tail,” he warned.

The Meyersdal Structural Collapse Incident Inquiry started its work yesterday, 29 October. First to take a stand yesterday were workers and contractor, Errol Romburgh from Romicon.

The inquiry follows the house collapse on 18 August in Meyersdal Eco Estate near Alberton that led to the death of seven workers, hospitalisation of nine and survival of eight workers. The Inquiry was set to sit until 7 November 2014 before today’s abrupt end.

Some of the questions though not exhaustive that Maphaha asked Galal include:

Were you involved in the project that led to the collapse of the structure?

Did you visit the site to prevent the collapse? if you did not do so it is a contravention!

Are you aware of the duties of designer/engineer in terms of Construction Regulations?

Was the structure in accordance with...