Turnbull-Jackson v Hibiscus Coast Municipality and Others

JurisdictionSouth Africa
CourtConstitutional Court
JudgeMoseneke ACJ, Skweyiya ADCJ, Cameron J, Dambuza AJ, Froneman J, Jafta J, Khampepe J, Madlanga J, Majiedt AJ, Van der Westhuizen J and Zondo J
Judgment Date11 September 2014
Citation2014 (6) SA 592 (CC)
Hearing Date04 February 2014
Docket NumberCCT 104/13 [2014] ZACC 24
CounselND Lange for the applicant. AM Annandale SC for the first respondent. ES Crots (with S Pudifin-Jones) for the second respondent. PJ Olsen SC for the amicus curiae.

Madlanga J (Moseneke ACJ, Skweyiya ADCJ, Dambuza AJ, Jafta J, Khampepe J, Majiedt AJ and Zondo J concurring): B

Introduction

[1] Not infrequently, applications for approval of building plans by municipalities give rise to legal disputes. This matter, which is characterised by unwelcome longevity, concerns that very subject. [1] Aggrieved C by a decision of the Hibiscus Coast Municipality [2] (municipality) to approve building plans submitted by Pearl Star Investments 14 CC [3] (Pearl Star), Mr Turnbull-Jackson [4] sought an order for the review and setting-aside of the approval. [5] His application was dismissed with costs by Sishi J in the KwaZulu-Natal High Court, Pietermaritzburg (high court). [6] With his application for leave to appeal having been unsuccessful D in both the high court and Supreme Court of Appeal, he now brings this application for leave to appeal against the judgment of the high court.

Building-plan approval process and the regulatory matrix E

[2] Before setting out the facts, it is important to lay out the building plan approval process as well as the applicable regulatory matrix. The National Building Regulations and Building Standards Act [7] were promulgated to provide for uniformity in the law relating to the erection of buildings within municipal areas. [8]

[3] The starting point is s 4. With the exception of exemptions provided F for in the Act, [9] this section proscribes the erection of buildings without

Madlanga J (Moseneke ACJ, Skweyiya ADCJ, Dambuza AJ, Jafta J, Khampepe J, Majiedt AJ and Zondo J concurring)

A the prior approval of building plans. [10] In terms of s 5 it is obligatory for every local authority to appoint a building control officer. This functionary has extensive powers that relate to the process of approving plans and inspection of construction works post approval. [11] Inspections are conducted to ensure that B building standards and materials comply with the Building Standards Act. [12] Section 6 of the Act stipulates that the building control officer must make recommendations to the local authority regarding applications for approval submitted in terms of s 4. [13]

[4] The approval process itself is governed by s 7. This section requires C to be quoted extensively because much turns on its provisions:

'(1) If a local authority, having considered a recommendation referred to in section 6(1)(a) —

(a)

is satisfied that the application in question complies with the requirements of this Act and any other applicable law, it shall grant its approval in respect thereof;

(b) (i)

D is not so satisfied; or

(ii)

is satisfied that the building to which the application in question relates —

(aa)

is to be erected in such manner or will be of such nature or appearance that —

(aaa)

E the area in which it is to be erected will probably or in fact be disfigured thereby;

(bbb)

it will probably or in fact be unsightly or objectionable;

(ccc)

it will probably or in fact derogate from the value of adjoining or neighbouring properties;

(bb)

F will probably or in fact be dangerous to life or property,

Madlanga J (Moseneke ACJ, Skweyiya ADCJ, Dambuza AJ, Jafta J, Khampepe J, Majiedt AJ and Zondo J concurring)

such local authority shall refuse to grant its approval in respect thereof A and give written reasons for such refusal.' [14]

[5] Another important provision is s 10, which enables the local authority to take action where it considers any building to be objectionable. It reads:

'(1) If any building or earthwork — B

(a)

in the opinion of the local authority in question is being or is to be erected in such manner that it —

(i)

will not be in the interest of good health or hygiene;

(ii)

will be unsightly or objectionable;

(iii)

will probably or in fact be a nuisance to the occupiers of C adjoining or neighbouring properties;

(iv)

will probably or in fact derogate from the value of adjoining or neighbouring properties;

(b)

is being or is to be erected on a site which is subject to flooding or on a site which or any portion of which in the opinion of the local authority in question does not drain properly or is filled up or covered with refuse or material impregnated with matter liable to D decomposition,

such local authority may by notice in writing, served by post or delivered, prohibit the person erecting such building or earthwork or causing such building or earthwork to be erected from commencing or proceeding with the erection thereof or from so commencing or proceeding except on such conditions as such local authority may E determine from time to time.

(2) Any person who fails to comply with any provision of a notice or condition referred to in subsection (1) shall be guilty of an offence and liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding R100 for each day on which he so failed.' F

[6] Also of relevance and application to the applicant's case is the Margate Transitional Local Council Town Planning Scheme (planning scheme). The provisions of the planning scheme help shed light on some of the applicant's challenges to the approval of Pearl Star's plans. The G planning scheme was promulgated in terms of the KwaZulu-Natal Town Planning Ordinance. [15] The purpose of the planning scheme is to promote the coordinated and harmonious development of the Margate Transitional Local Council [16] area in such a way as will most effectively tend to promote health, safety, order, amenity convenience and general welfare, as well as efficiency and economy in the process of development, H and the improvement of communications. [17] Any proposal or application to develop or use land and/or buildings within a local authority area must have regard to the provisions of the planning scheme. [18]

Madlanga J (Moseneke ACJ, Skweyiya ADCJ, Dambuza AJ, Jafta J, Khampepe J, Majiedt AJ and Zondo J concurring)

A [7] The provisions relevant to this case relate to: zoning; what constitutes a basement and related issues; and the regulation of the use of side spaces. In terms of zoning, clause 3.1.2 states that a land-use zone is a portion of land located within the local authority area in terms of which certain uses of land, buildings and structures are imposed and regulations B pertaining to their use and development specified. Clause 4.2.6 provides that in the Margate section of the planning scheme buildings are permitted to have a height of six storeys, except certain specified lots where height is restricted to two storeys. The planning scheme permits six-storey developments on general residential land-use zones without any form of special consent or other permission. [19] If a proposed C development on this type of zone consists of more than three storeys, the building must be recessed away from the normal building lines and side spaces on the lot by a specified distance for each additional storey. [20] This must be meant to lessen the intrusive effects of overlooking.

[8] The planning scheme defines a basement in clause 2.20. It is the —

D 'lowest part of any structure where such part is constructed with a basement ceiling level not more than one metre above the lesser of either the finished ground level or the natural ground level immediately surrounding the building, at any point (excluding entrance and exit ramps)'.

E Further, clause 2.160 in relevant part defines a storey as —

'a room or set of rooms at any level, including any room the floor of which is split into two or more levels, and shall have the following implications:

(a)

(A)ny basement not used for residential or work place purposes F but used solely for the purpose of parking vehicles, service installations, such as transformer and meter rooms, or storage shall not count as a storey for the purpose of calculating permissible height provided such an area or areas constitute a basement in terms of this Scheme.'

[9] Regarding side-space regulation, the planning scheme imposes the G following restrictions:

'9.2

Side and rear space

(i)

Except as otherwise stated no building shall be erected nearer than 2.5 metres to any side or rear boundary.

. . .

(iv)

H The Local Authority may, by special consent, permit in any zone any building to be erected closer to any boundary than the distances specified in this clause if on account of the siting of existing buildings or the shape, size or levels of the lot, the enforcement of this clause will, in the opinion of the Local Authority, render the development of the lot unreasonably difficult. I In considering any application under this sub-clause the Local Authority shall have due regard to any possible detrimental effect on adjoining properties.

Madlanga J (Moseneke ACJ, Skweyiya ADCJ, Dambuza AJ, Jafta J, Khampepe J, Majiedt AJ and Zondo J concurring)

(v)

Notwithstanding the aforegoing provisions, the Local Authority A may, if special circumstances exist, exempt an applicant from applying for special consent if it is satisfied that no interference with the amenities of the neighbourhood, existing, or as contemplated by this scheme, will result; provided that the prior written consent of the registered owner of each adjoining property, and B such other properties as the Town Clerk may direct, has first been obtained. Where any such written consent is not forthcoming, the applicant shall, in seeking the relaxations, be required to apply for the Local Authority's Special Consent.'

Factual background C

[10] The history is long and perplexing. During late 2003 Pearl Star submitted plans to the municipality to construct a six-storey apartment block on its property. [21] In February 2004 the municipality, acting through its employee, Mr Van der Walt, [22] approved Pearl Star's building plans (2004 approval). This approval was set...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex
27 practice notes
  • Oudekraal after Fifteen Years: The Second Act (or, A Reassessment of the Status and Force of Defective Administrative Decisions Pending Judicial Review)
    • South Africa
    • Juta Stellenbosch Law Review No. , June 2020
    • 1 June 2020
    ...& F Bosma n Introduction to Sou th African Law and Legal T heory (1983) 232-236; Turnbull-Jackson v Hibis cus Court Munici pality 2014 6 SA 592 (CC) paras 61 and 6248 2006 1 SA 252 (SCA)49 Para 10 Nugent JA, the other co -author of Oudekraal, was one of the c oncurring judges i n this matte......
  • Removal of the National Director of Public Prosecution : a critique of emerging constitutional jurisprudence
    • South Africa
    • Sabinet Southern African Public Law No. 35-2, July 2020
    • 1 July 2020
    ...Deputy National and consistency; Peters and Another v S [2019] ZAECPEHC 31; Turnbull-Jackson v Hibiscus Court Municipality and Others 2014 (6) SA 592 (CC) paras 53−56; True Motives 84 (Pty) Ltd v Mahdi and Another 2009 (4) SA 153 (SCA) para 100; Brown and Another v Papadakis NO and Another ......
  • Democratic principles underpinning tax administration in SA
    • South Africa
    • Sabinet Business Tax and Company Law Quarterly No. 10-4, December 2019
    • 1 December 2019
    ...held further (at para 28): ‘To deviate from this rule is to invite legal chaos.’ Also, see Turnbull-Jackson v Hibiscus Coast Municipality 2014 6 SA 592 (CC) at para 55. 54 Decisions of the Tax Board and Tax Court are binding only on immediate parties. See Estate Brownson v President and Mem......
  • Bwanya v the Master of the High Court and Others
    • South Africa
    • Invalid date
    ...(SCA) (2009 (7) BCLR 712; [2009] 2 All SA 548; [2009] ZASCA 4): referred to Turnbull-Jackson v Hibiscus Coast Municipality and Others 2014 (6) SA 592 (CC) (2014 (11) BCLR 1310; [2014] ZACC 24): referred to United Democratic Movement v Speaker, National Assembly and Others 2017 (5) SA 300 (C......
  • Get Started for Free
18 cases
  • Bwanya v the Master of the High Court and Others
    • South Africa
    • Invalid date
    ...(SCA) (2009 (7) BCLR 712; [2009] 2 All SA 548; [2009] ZASCA 4): referred to Turnbull-Jackson v Hibiscus Coast Municipality and Others 2014 (6) SA 592 (CC) (2014 (11) BCLR 1310; [2014] ZACC 24): referred to United Democratic Movement v Speaker, National Assembly and Others 2017 (5) SA 300 (C......
  • Ruta v Minister of Home Affairs
    • South Africa
    • Constitutional Court
    • 20 December 2018
    ...See general facts set out in Bula above n 31. [66] Id at para 75. [67] Turnbull-Jackson v Hibiscus Coast Municipality [2014] ZACC 24; 2014 (6) SA 592 (CC); 2014 (11) BCLR 1310 (CC) at para [68] True Motives 84 (Pty) Ltd v Mahdi [2009] ZASCA 4; 2009 (4) SA 153 (SCA) at para 100, quoted and e......
  • DA Cruz and Another v Cape Town City and Another
    • South Africa
    • Western Cape Division, Cape Town
    • 13 January 2017
    ...2015 (4) SA 229 (SCA) ([2015] 3 All SA 161; [2015] ZASCA 45): referred to Turnbull-Jackson v Hibiscus Coast Municipality and Others 2014 (6) SA 592 (CC) (2014 (11) BCLR 1310; [2014] ZACC 24): discussed and applied Walele v City of Cape Town and Others 2008 (6) SA 129 (CC) (2008 (11) BCLR 10......
  • Laubscher NO v Duplan and Others
    • South Africa
    • Constitutional Court
    • 30 November 2016
    ...union). [8] 25 of 1961. [9] Gory above n4 para 43. [10] Id para 66. [11] See Turnbull-Jackson v Hibiscus Coast Municipality and Others 2014 (6) SA 592 (CC) (2014 (11) BCLR 1310; [2014] ZACC 24) para [12] Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie (Doctors for Life International and Others, Amici Cur......
  • Get Started for Free
3 books & journal articles