Stewart and Another v Botha and Another

JurisdictionSouth Africa
Judgment Date07 May 2007
Citation2007 (6) SA 247 (C)

Stewart and Another v Botha and Another [*]
2007 (6) SA 247 (C)

2007 (6) SA p247


Citation

2007 (6) SA 247 (C)

Case No

10929/2004

Court

Cape Provincial Division

Judge

Louw J

Heard

April 20, 2006

Judgment

May 7, 2007

Counsel

A C Oosthuizen SC for the plaintiffs
M Daling for the first defendant

Flynote : Sleutelwoorde C

Negligence — Liability for — Wrongful birth and wrongful life actions — Wrongful life D — Child born with severe congenital physical disabilities — Whether natural guardian entitled to sue doctors in delict on child's behalf for future damages — Doctors negligently failing to diagnose or inform parents of potential birth defects to enable them to make E informed decision whether to abort foetus — Doctors' negligent conduct and breach of professional duties causing child to be born — Doctors not causing severe state of disability in which child born — Doctors' negligent conduct legally irrelevant to child's disabled state — Wrongful life claim not disclosing cause of action. F

Negligence — Liability for — Wrongful birth and wrongful life actions — Wrongful life — Whether disclosing cause of action. Semble: Not against public policy to allow wrongful life action — Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996 permitting mother to abort potentially deformed child — No valid reason for refusing wrongful life action on basis of sanctity of G life when wrongful pregnancy and wrongful birth actions not disallowed for this reason — Objection to wrongful life claim not relating to difficulty in assessing damages but fundamental question of whether child suffered damage at all.

Parent and child — Right of action against parents — Right of disabled child to sue parents. Semble: Where parents of disabled child allowing child to be H conceived or born whilst knowing risks such parents exercising constitutional right to reproductive choice — Whether disabled child having right to sue parents depending on circumstances and views of community incorporating constitutional values and norms — Whether having right to sue not following from or depending on whether disabled child having right to sue doctor. I

Headnote : Kopnota

A child was born with severe physical disabilities which led his father (the second plaintiff), on the child's behalf, to sue the general medical practitioner and

2007 (6) SA p248

specialist gynaecologist and obstetrician (the defendants) who had treated the child's mother during her A pregnancy. The second plaintiff claimed the damages suffered by the child in respect of future medical treatment necessitated by his disability, the cost of his special schooling and maintenance for the rest of his life. The basis for this claim was 'wrongful life'. The second plaintiff claimed that the defendants had been negligent in failing to detect and inform the child's mother of the congenital deformities and abnormalities of the foetus that could result in the B child being born severely disabled; failing to advise the mother of the risk of the child being born with such abnormalities and failing to advise her on a termination of pregnancy.

The second plaintiff alleged that, had the mother been informed of the high risk of the child being born with severe physical disabilities, she would have elected to terminate the pregnancy. Since the doctors C did not cause the defects, the second plaintiff's claim was that but for the conduct of the defendants, the child would not have been born at all. The defendants contended that a wrongful life claim was not recognised in South African law and therefore raised the exception that the particulars of claim disclosed no cause of action. D

Held, that the defendants had owed a duty to the unborn child properly to advise his mother during her pregnancy to enable her to make an informed decision on whether or not to abort her foetus. (Paragraph [22] at 258E - F.)

Held, further, that although the defendants' negligent conduct and their breach of the professional duties owed to the pregnant mother and her child had caused the child to be born, the E severe state of disability in which he was born was not caused by the defendants since it was inevitable that if he were to be born at all, he would be born in exactly the state of severe disability in which he was born. The only life ever possible for the child was a life in the handicapped state in which he was born. The negligent conduct of the defendants was legally irrelevant to the state in which the child was born. (Paragraph [30] at 262B - D.) F

Held, accordingly, that the second plaintiff's claim did not disclose a cause of action in our law. (Paragraph [31] at 262E.) Exception upheld with costs.

Semble: Regarding the argument that the action should be refused on the basis that it would be against public policy to hold that it would be better not to live than to live in an impaired state (the 'sanctity of life argument'): first, this argument had been G eroded in South Africa by the provisions in the Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996 that permit the mother in specific circumstances to abort her potentially deformed child. Secondly, there did not appear to be any valid reason for being more accommodating towards the parents' claims and for holding that, where the mother was H the plaintiff ('wrongful birth' and 'wrongful pregnancy'), the sanctity of life argument did not prevent the action while where the disabled child was the plaintiff ('wrongful life'), the sanctity of life argument was an insurmountable obstacle to the claim. (Paragraphs [17], [18], [20] and [21] at 255B - C, 255I/J and 257E - F.)

Semble: Regarding the argument that a wrongful life claim would open the door for disabled children to sue their parents because I they may have allowed the child to be conceived or born, knowing the risks: such parents would have been exercising their constitutional right to make decisions concerning reproduction, and whether this would be held to be unlawful vis-à-vis the child would depend on the circumstances and views of the community incorporating the values and norms of the Constitution of the Republic of J

2007 (6) SA p249

South Africa, 1996. It would not follow from or be determined by whether the child had a right to sue the doctor in such A circumstances. (Paragraph [23] at 259A - D.)

Semble: The objection to the second plaintiff's claim was not the difficulty in assessing the damage (the difference in value between existence and non-existence) but the more fundamental question of whether the disabled child had suffered damage at all. (Paragraphs [24] and [29] at 259E and 261F.) B

Cases Considered

Annotations

Reported cases

Southern African cases C

Administrator, Natal v Edouard 1990 (3) SA 581 (A): referred to

Christian Lawyers Association of SA and Others v Minister of Health and Others 1998 (4) SA 1113 (T) (1998 (11) BCLR 1434): referred to

Christian Lawyers Association v Minister of Health and Others (Reproductive Health Alliance as Amicus Curiae) 2005 (1) SA 509 (T) (2004 (10) BCLR 1086; [2004] 4 All SA 31): D referred to

Friedman v Glicksman 1996 (1) SA 1134 (W): dictum at 1142I - 1143C discussed and criticised

Griffiths v Mutual & Federal Insurance Co Ltd 1994 (1) SA 535 (A): referred to

Jowell v Bramwell-Jones and Others 2000 (3) SA 274 (SCA) ([2000] 2 All SA 161): referred to E

Southern Insurance Association Ltd v Bailey NO 1984 (1) SA 98 (A): referred to

Transnet Ltd v Sechaba Photoscan (Pty) Ltd 2005 (1) SA 299 (SCA): referred to.

Foreign cases

Becker v Schwartz 386 NE 2d 807 (NY 1978): referred to F

Bruggeman v Schimke 718 P 2d 635 (Kan 1986): referred to

Curlender v Bio-Science Laboratories 106 Cal App 3d 811: referred to

Harbison v Park-Davis Incorporated Wash 659 P 2d 483: referred to

Harriton v Stephens (2006) 226 CLR 52 ((2006) 226 ALR 391; (2006) 80 ALJR 791; (2006) HCA 15): referred to G

Lacroix (Guardian of) v Dominique (2001) 202 DLR (4th) 121 ([2001] MBCA 122): referred to

McFarlane v Tayside Health Board [2000] 2 AC 59 (HL): dictum at 83F - G applied

McKay and Another v Essex Area Health Authority and Another [1982] 2 All ER 771 (CA): referred to H

Philips v United States 508 F Supp 537 (1980): referred to

Procanik v Cillo 478 A 2d 755: referred to

Speck v Finegold Pa 268 Super 342 (1979) (408 A 2d 496): referred to

Turpin v Sortini 643 P 2d 954 (Cal 1982): referred to.

Statutes Considered

Statutes I

The Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996, s 2: see Juta's Statutes of South Africa 2006/7 vol 1 at 3-196.

Case Information

Exception to a claim for damages for 'wrongful life'. The facts appear from the reasons for judgment.

A C Oosthuizen SC for the plaintiffs. J

2007 (6) SA p250

M Daling for the first defendant.

G van der Spuy for the second defendant. A

Cur adv vult.

Postea (May 7).

Judgment

Louw J:

[1] The plaintiffs in this action for damages are the natural parents of B Stewart (to whom I shall refer as 'B') who was born B on 4 August 1993 with severe physical disabilities. The plaintiffs' claims arise from B's birth in his disabled state and are brought against the general medical practitioner (the first defendant) and against the specialist obstetrician and C gynaecologist (the second defendant), who treated and advised B's mother, the first plaintiff, during the course of her pregnancy with B.

[2] The first plaintiff, who is B's mother, claims in her personal capacity in contract, alternatively in delict, for damages in the amount of R2,66 million in respect of past and future medical expenses occasioned by B's condition, expenses in regard to special D schooling for B and for the maintenance of B for the rest of his life, which is estimated to be 50 years.

[3] B's father, the second plaintiff, sues in...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex
5 practice notes
  • H v Fetal Assessment Centre
    • South Africa
    • December 11, 2014
    ...Board, Eastern Cape 2007 (3) SA 121 (CC) (2007 (3) BCLR 300; [2006] ZACC 16): referred to F Stewart and Another v Botha and Another 2007 (6) SA 247 (C) (2007 (9) BCLR 1012): referred Stewart and Another v Botha and Another 2008 (6) SA 310 (SCA): criticised Telematrix (Pty) Ltd t/a Matrix Ve......
  • “Wrongful Life” – The Constitutional Court Paved the Way for Law Reform
    • South Africa
    • Juta Stellenbosch Law Review No. , May 2019
    • May 27, 2019
    ...li fe”; I Giesen “The Use and Inf luence of Comparative L aw in ‘Wrongful Life’ Case s” (2012) 8 Utrecht L Rev 35 36.2 Fi rst in 2007 6 SA 247 (C) and then in t he SCA: 2008 6 SA 310 (SCA). The other South Afric an cases on this issue ar e Friedman v Glicksma n 1996 1 SA 1134 (W) and (now a......
  • Wrongful Life Claims: A Failure to Develop the Common Law?
    • South Africa
    • Juta Stellenbosch Law Review No. , August 2019
    • August 16, 2019
    ...rongful birth ac tions, simultaneo usly rejected wro ngful life clai ms This was co nfirmed i n the later decision of S tewart v Botha 2007 6 SA 247 (C) and Stewart v Botha 2008 6 SA 310 (SCA)22 1990 3 SA 581 (A)23 595 D- F24 In the United St ates the fi rst insta nce involving wr ongful co......
  • Stewart and Another v Botha and Another
    • South Africa
    • June 3, 2008
    ...refused the claim on exception. (Paragraph [29] at 319G.) Appeal dismissed. The decision in Stewart and Another v Botha and Another 2007 (6) SA 247 (C) (2007 (9) BCLR 1012) Cases Considered Annotations H Reported cases Southern African cases Administrator, Natal v Edouard 1990 (3) SA 581 (A......
  • Get Started for Free
3 cases
  • H v Fetal Assessment Centre
    • South Africa
    • December 11, 2014
    ...Board, Eastern Cape 2007 (3) SA 121 (CC) (2007 (3) BCLR 300; [2006] ZACC 16): referred to F Stewart and Another v Botha and Another 2007 (6) SA 247 (C) (2007 (9) BCLR 1012): referred Stewart and Another v Botha and Another 2008 (6) SA 310 (SCA): criticised Telematrix (Pty) Ltd t/a Matrix Ve......
  • Stewart and Another v Botha and Another
    • South Africa
    • June 3, 2008
    ...refused the claim on exception. (Paragraph [29] at 319G.) Appeal dismissed. The decision in Stewart and Another v Botha and Another 2007 (6) SA 247 (C) (2007 (9) BCLR 1012) Cases Considered Annotations H Reported cases Southern African cases Administrator, Natal v Edouard 1990 (3) SA 581 (A......
  • Lubbe NO and Others v Millennium Style (Pty) Ltd and Others; Lubbe and Others NNO v Millennium Style (Pty) Ltd
    • South Africa
    • March 16, 2007
    ...with costs, including those consequent upon the employment of two counsel. Brand JA, Cloete JA, Ponnan JA and Cachalia JA concurred. F 2007 (6) SA p247 Harms ADP Appellants' Attorneys: Dr Gerntholtz Inc, Cape Town; J Leslie Smith & Co, Pietermaritzburg; A McIntyre & Van der Post, Bloemfonte......
2 books & journal articles
  • “Wrongful Life” – The Constitutional Court Paved the Way for Law Reform
    • South Africa
    • Juta Stellenbosch Law Review No. , May 2019
    • May 27, 2019
    ...li fe”; I Giesen “The Use and Inf luence of Comparative L aw in ‘Wrongful Life’ Case s” (2012) 8 Utrecht L Rev 35 36.2 Fi rst in 2007 6 SA 247 (C) and then in t he SCA: 2008 6 SA 310 (SCA). The other South Afric an cases on this issue ar e Friedman v Glicksma n 1996 1 SA 1134 (W) and (now a......
  • Wrongful Life Claims: A Failure to Develop the Common Law?
    • South Africa
    • Juta Stellenbosch Law Review No. , August 2019
    • August 16, 2019
    ...rongful birth ac tions, simultaneo usly rejected wro ngful life clai ms This was co nfirmed i n the later decision of S tewart v Botha 2007 6 SA 247 (C) and Stewart v Botha 2008 6 SA 310 (SCA)22 1990 3 SA 581 (A)23 595 D- F24 In the United St ates the fi rst insta nce involving wr ongful co......