Plotkin v Western Assurance Co Ltd and Another
| Jurisdiction | South Africa |
| Court | Witwatersrand Local Division |
| Judge | Ramsbottom J |
| Judgment Date | 25 January 1955 |
| Citation | 1955 (2) SA 385 (W) |
| Hearing Date | 24 January 1955 |
H Ramsbottom, J.:
This is an exception to a declaration in which the plaintiff claims damages which he alleges that he has sustained as the result of injuries caused to his wife to whom he is married out of community of property.
Ramsbottom J
The declaration alleges that on July 17th, 1952, a collision occurred between a motor cycle driven by one Poley and a motor van driven by one Dissel, and that in consequence of that collision the motor cycle ran into the plaintiff's wife and caused her serious injury. It is alleged that the collision and the injury to the plaintiff's wife were caused A either by the negligence of Poley, or by the negligence of Dissel, or by the combined negligence of both. It is alleged that at the time of the collision the first defendant was the insurer of the motor cycle and that the second defendant was the insurer of the motor van; in terms of Act 29 of 1942, and that the two defendants had issued declarations of insurance to Poley and Dissel respectively in terms of the said Act.
B The plaintiff alleges that he carries on the business of a garage proprietor and (para. 4 (a)) that at the time of the accident his wife 'was employed in and about the business of the plaintiff as aforesaid and assisted the plaintiff therein by reason of the fact that such employment and assistance by the plaintiff's said wife was essential to the upkeep and maintenance of the joint household then and at all material times subsisting between the plaintiff and his said wife'.
C He alleges further (para. 4 (b)) that:
'In the premises and by reason of the foregoing the plaintiff was on the said date and at all material times owed a legal and lawful duty by his said wife to employ herself and to assist the plaintiff in carrying on his said business.'
The plaintiff alleges that as a result of the injuries which his wife D suffered she was totally disabled from being employed in and assisting the plaintiff in his business for a period of 14 months, and that in consequence he has suffered damages in the sum of £840 which he claims from one or other or both of the defendants.
In reply to a request for further particulars made by the first defendant, the plaintiff has stated that
'it is not alleged that any specific agreement was concluded between the E plaintiff and his said wife, but it is intended to allege that the plaintiff's said wife was under a legal duty to assist the plaintiff in carrying on his business in so far as such assistance was essential to the upkeep of the joint household',
and that when he acquired the business the employment and assistance of his wife therein was in pursuance of her legal duty and was essential to the upkeep and maintenance of the joint household, and that his wife
F 'was obliged to employ herself and assist the plaintiff in the said business for so long as such employment and assistance was essential to the upkeep and maintenance of the joint household'.
The plaintiff states further that no specific duties were assigned to his wife but that she acted
G 'in the place of a manager whom the plaintiff would otherwise have been obliged to employ'.
He states that no remuneration was agreed upon, but the employment and assistance of his wife enabled him
'to dispense with the services of a manager whom he would otherwise have required in the said business and whose salary would have been not less than £60 per month'.
The plaintiff states that the sum of £840 which he claims as damages 'represents fourteen months during which the plaintiff's said wife was H totally disabled to employ herself in the plaintiff's said business and to assist him therein, and during that period the plaintiff was obliged to obtain other assistance in the said business in the place of his said wife at a cost of £60 per month, which sum is and was at all material times a fair and reasonable sum'.
Further particulars were also furnished at the request of the second defendant, but with those I am not now concerned.
Ramsbottom J
Both defendants, separately, have filed exceptions to the declaration on the ground that it is bad in law and discloses no cause of action. The exception of the first defendant only has been heard, and it is with the first defendant's exception alone that I am concerned.
The contention put forward by Mr. Hart on behalf of the excipient was A that a husband can only claim for damages suffered through the loss of the assistance given him by his wife if the wife was under a legal duty to render such assistance; that a wife married out of community of property is not, in law, obliged to assist her husband in his business; and that the declaration therefore discloses no cause of action.
It is clearly correct that an action of this sort lies only when the B person who was killed or injured was under a legal duty to assist the plaintiff. In Union Government v Warneke, 1911 AD 657, INNES, J.A., at p. 666, said:
'So that in all the cases actually mentioned in the books, the right of the claimant to demand assistance was a right of property, the deprivation of which by the culpa of the defendant would quite naturally found a claim for patrimonial damages. I can find no authority for the C proposition that the law of Holland would have given an action of this nature to any relation not damnified by being deprived of benefits supplied by the deceased under a legal duty to do so. I do not think that we should depart from the principles to which I have drawn attention, and it only remains to consider whether consistently with their observance the statements in the declaration make out a case for relief.'
In Warneke's case it was decided that
'every wife is bound to supervise or assist, according to the D circumstances, in the care and upbringing of the children of the marriage',
that
'this is a legal duty which she owes not merely to the children, but to her husband, who is entitled to demand her assistance in bearing a burden which the law has imposed upon them both',
and
'that being so there is nothing inconsistent with the principles of our E law in allowing a husband who can show that his pecuniary expenditure in connection with the maintenance of his children has been directly and necessarily increased owing to the death of his wife to claim damages against the person who has negligently caused her death'.
(per INNES, J.A. at p. 669).
In Abbott v Bergman, 1922 AD 53, the plaintiff's wife, to whom he was F married in community of property, had been injured but had not been killed. The husband claimed damages for expense incurred by him in medical and hospital fees, and for damage which he had sustained through the loss of his wife's services in running a boarding-house. It was held that the declaration disclosed a cause of action.
G Mr. Hart did not contend that a husband married in community of property could not claim for damage which he had sustained through the loss of his wife's services in his business, but he argued that that was a loss suffered by the joint estate for which the husband could sue. His contention was that a husband married out of community of property had no right to demand the assistance of his wife in his business, and therefore, in the present case, the plaintiff's declaration discloses no H cause of action. The question, then, is whether a wife, married out of community of property, owes a legal duty to assist him in his business if such assistance is 'essential to the upkeep and maintenance of the joint household'...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Start Your 7-day Trial
-
Public Policy in Family Contracts, Part II: Antenuptial Contracts
...Fox Co L td (1951) 2 KB 639 665 as quot ed in Gr obbelaar v Have nga 1964 3 SA 522 (N) 525E51 Plotkin v Wester n Assurance Co Ltd 1955 2 SA 385 (W); Mühlmann v Mühlmann 1981 4 SA 632 (W) 52 MA Fineman “ Why Marriage?” (20 01) 9 Virginia Journal of Soci al Policy and the Law 239 2 6453 KB Si......
-
Road Accident Fund v Krawa
... ... Boompret Investments (Pty) Ltd and Another v Paardekraal Concession Store (Pty) Ltd 1990 (1) SA 347 (A): referred ... Milns v Protea Assurance Co Ltd 1978 (3) SA 1006 (C): referred to ... N Goodwin Design ... 2012 (2) SA p348 ... Plotkin v Western Assurance Co Ltd and Another 1955 (2) SA 385 (W): referred to ... ...
-
Brooks v Minister of Safety and Security
...thereof by Greenberg J (as he then was) in De Vaal NO v Messing 1938 TPD 34. Also see Plotkin v Western Assurance Co Ltd and Another 1955 (2) SA 385 (W); and Erdmann v Santam Insurance Co Ltd 1985 (3) SA 402 (C). I [10] 1999 (3) SA 421 (SCA) [also reported at [1999] 2 All SA 312 - [11] 1999......
-
Has the Time Come to Abolish or Adapt the Husband’s Common-Law Right to his Wife’s Domestic Services?
...de ned in purely nancial term s and, as the quote from Plotkin shows, rested on ly upon 5 1922 AD 53.6 1938 WLD 260.7 1938 WLD 260.8 1955 2 SA 385 (W).9 221.10 Some cases ba se it on the duty to provid e spousa l suppor t, while others mention the s pousal du ty to contribut e to the comm......
-
Brooks v Minister of Safety and Security
...State Tender Board and Another 2001 (3) SA 1247 (SCA) (2001 (8) BCLR 779): referred to Plotkin v Western Assurance Co Ltd and Another 1955 (2) SA 385 (W): referred Santam Bank v Henery 1999 (3) SA 421 (SCA) ([1999] 2 All SA 312): F referred to Suid-Afrikaanse Nasionale Trust en Assuransie M......
-
Road Accident Fund v Krawa
...Mining Co (Ltd) v Dreyfus (1885) 2 Buch AC 98: dictum at 101 applied J 2012 (2) SA p348 Plotkin v Western Assurance Co Ltd and Another 1955 (2) SA 385 (W): referred to A President Insurance Co Ltd v Mathews 1992 (1) SA 1 (A): dictum at 5C – D Price NO v Allied – JBS Building Society 1980 (3......
-
Brooks v Minister of Safety and Security
...thereof by Greenberg J (as he then was) in De Vaal NO v Messing 1938 TPD 34. Also see Plotkin v Western Assurance Co Ltd and Another 1955 (2) SA 385 (W); and Erdmann v Santam Insurance Co Ltd 1985 (3) SA 402 (C). I [10] 1999 (3) SA 421 (SCA) [also reported at [1999] 2 All SA 312 - [11] 1999......
-
Ismail v General Accident Insurance Co SA Ltd
...decided cases, viz Christie NO v Estate Christie and Another 1956 (3) SA 659 (N); Plotkin v Western Assurance Co Ltd and Another 1955 (2) SA 385 (W); Oosthuizen v Stanley 1938 AD 322; Union Government (Minister of Railways and Harbours) v Warneke 1911 AD 657 and Milns v Protea Assurance Co ......
-
Public Policy in Family Contracts, Part II: Antenuptial Contracts
...Fox Co L td (1951) 2 KB 639 665 as quot ed in Gr obbelaar v Have nga 1964 3 SA 522 (N) 525E51 Plotkin v Wester n Assurance Co Ltd 1955 2 SA 385 (W); Mühlmann v Mühlmann 1981 4 SA 632 (W) 52 MA Fineman “ Why Marriage?” (20 01) 9 Virginia Journal of Soci al Policy and the Law 239 2 6453 KB Si......
-
Has the Time Come to Abolish or Adapt the Husband’s Common-Law Right to his Wife’s Domestic Services?
...de ned in purely nancial term s and, as the quote from Plotkin shows, rested on ly upon 5 1922 AD 53.6 1938 WLD 260.7 1938 WLD 260.8 1955 2 SA 385 (W).9 221.10 Some cases ba se it on the duty to provid e spousa l suppor t, while others mention the s pousal du ty to contribut e to the comm......