BE Bop a Lula Manufacturing & Printing CC v Kingtex Marketing (Pty) Ltd

JurisdictionSouth Africa
Judgment Date25 August 2006
Citation2006 (6) SA 379 (C)

BE Bop a Lula Manufacturing & Printing CC v Kingtex Marketing (Pty) Ltd
2006 (6) SA 379 (C)

2006 (6) SA p379


Citation

2006 (6) SA 379 (C)

Case No

A963/2005

Court

Cape Provincial Division

Judge

Van Zyl J, Waglay J and Ndita J

Heard

July 28, 2006

Judgment

August 25, 2006

Counsel

S P Rosenberg SC for the appellant.
J Viljoen for the respondent.

Flynote : Sleutelwoorde G

Payment — 'In full and final settlement' — Effect of — Topic revisited and certain general principles distilled. H

Compromise — Payment 'in full and final settlement' — Whether amounting to offer of I compromise — Tender of cheque 'in full and final settlement' — Ordinarily amounting to offer of compromise — True intention of parties to be ascertained — Where tender of cheque 'in full and final settlement' never intended to amount to offer of compromise, no offer of compromise concluded.

Compromise — Offer of — Acceptance — Whether depositing of cheque 'in full and final settlement' amounting to acceptance of offer of compromise J

2006 (6) SA p380

— This ordinarily so — True intention of parties to be A ascertained — Where depositing of cheque never intended to amount to acceptance of offer of compromise, no acceptance of offer.

Headnote : Kopnota

In an action for payment for goods sold and delivered, the defendant raised the defence that it had tendered a cheque 'in B full and final settlement' of the plaintiff's claim and that the plaintiff had deposited the cheque into its bank account, ie it raised a plea of compromise. The trial Court found that the plaintiff had not accepted the defendant's offer of compromise and dismissed the defendant's plea. In an appeal to a Full Bench the Court found that: (1) while the tender of a cheque endorsed 'in full and final settlement' ordinarily constituted an offer of compromise, on the C evidence, the cheque tendered by the defendant endorsed 'in full and final settlement' had not been intended to be such an offer; (2) while the depositing of a cheque endorsed 'in full and final settlement' ordinarily constituted acceptance of an offer of compromise, on the evidence, the plaintiff's depositing of the defendant's cheque endorsed 'in full and final settlement' had not been intended to be acceptance of the defendant's offer (if it D were one); and (3) in the circumstances the parties had not concluded an agreement of compromise. Appeal dismissed. (Paragraphs [42] and [45] - [49] at 392E - 393D and 393I - 394H.)

Case Information

Annotations

Reported cases E

Absa Bank Ltd v Van de Vyver NO 2002 (4) SA 397 (SCA): dicta at 402B - F and 404G - I applied

Andy's Electrical v Laurie Sykes (Pty) Ltd 1979 (3) SA 341 (N): referred to

Burt NO v National Bank of South Africa Ltd 1921 AD 59: dicta at 62 and 67 applied F

Cachalia v Harberer & Co 1905 TS 457: referred to

Dennis Peters Investments (Pty) Ltd v Ollerenshaw and Others 1977 (1) SA 197 (W): referred to

Gollach & Gomperts (1967) (Pty) Ltd v Universal Mills & Produce Co (Pty) Ltd and Others 1978 (1) SA 914 (A): referred to

Harris v Pieters 1920 AD 644: referred to G

Jonathan v Haggie Rand Wire Ltd and Another 1978 (2) SA 34 (N): referred to

Karson v Minister of Public Works 1996 (1) SA 887 (E): referred to

Kei Brick & Tile Co (Pty) Ltd v A M Construction 1996 (1) SA 150 (E): referred to

Marendaz v Marendaz 1953 (4) SA 218 (C): H referred to

Meyer v Louw (1832) 2 Menzies 8: referred to

Mothle v Mathole 1951 (1) SA 785 (T): referred to

National Employers' General Insurance Co Ltd v Springbok Timber & Hardware Co (Pty) Ltd 1969 (3) SA 444 (W): referred to

Neville v Plasket 1935 TPD 115: referred to

Odendaal v Du Plessis 1918 AD 470: I referred to

Paterson Exhibitions CC v Knights Advertising and Marketing CC 1991 (3) SA 523 (A): dictum at 529B - D applied

Steenkamp v Union Government 1947 (1) SA 449 (C): referred to

Tauber v Von Abo 1984 (4) SA 482 (E): referred to

The Torch Moderne Binnehuis Vervaardiging Venn (Edms) Bpk v Husserl 1946 CPD 548: referred to J

2006 (6) SA p381

Trust Bank van Afrika Bpk v Ungerer 1981 (2) SA 223 (T): referred to A

Van Breukelen en 'n Ander v Van Breukelen 1966 (2) SA 285 (A): referred to

Van Schalkwyk v Pienaar's Trustees (1898) 15 SC 288: referred to

Van Zyl v Niemann 1964 (4) SA 661 (A): referred to

Zandberg v Van Zyl 1910 AD 302: referred to.

Case Information

Appeal from a decision of a single Judge in the same Division (Traverso DJP). The facts appear from the judgment of Van Zyl J. B

S P Rosenberg SC for the appellant.

J Viljoen for the respondent.

Cur adv vult.

Postea (August 25). C

Judgment

Van Zyl J:

Introduction

[1] This is an appeal with leave of the Court a quo (Traverso DJP) against the judgment upholding the claim in convention D of the respondent, as plaintiff, against the appellant, as defendant. There is no cross-appeal in regard to the successful claim in reconvention of the appellant against the respondent. Mr S P Rosenberg SC appeared for the appellant and Mr J Viljoen for the respondent. The Court expresses its E appreciation to them for their respective presentations in this matter.

[2] The claim in convention was directed at payment of the amount of R122 649,18, being the balance owing in respect of certain T-shirts sold and delivered by the respondent, a company doing business in Pretoria West, to the appellant, a close corporation with F its main place of business in Parow. According to the respondent's particulars of claim, the appellant had purchased T-shirts from it in the amount of R229 846,07, but had paid only R107 196,89 in respect thereof, hence leaving the aforesaid balance payable.

[3] In its plea the appellant denied being liable to the respondent in the amount claimed, averring that a large portion of G the T-shirts supplied to it by the respondent had been defective. In the alternative, it pleaded that it had tendered the aforesaid amount of R107 196,89 in full and final settlement of the respondent's initial claim of R229 846,07. This constituted a plea of compromise, which, in fact, became the primary issue between the parties in the trial and, indeed, remains so in the present appeal. H

[4] The appellant's claim in reconvention, which was conditional on the trial Court's rejecting the plea of compromise, was for payment of the amount of R80 000. This constituted damages suffered by it, in that the respondent had supplied only 40 000 of the 60 000 T-shirts it had purchased from the respondent. I Inasmuch as the appellant had an agreement with one of its customers, namely Adidas, in terms of which it would on-sell these garments to Adidas, at a profit of R4 per T-shirt, the respondent's failure to supply the appellant with 20 000 T-shirts had caused it to suffer a loss of profit in the said amount of R80 000. J

2006 (6) SA p382

Van Zyl J

The evidence A

[5] The nub of the appellant's case in regard to the compromise issue is that it paid the respondent a cheque, dated 28 February 2002, in the amount of R107 196,89. The cheque was signed by a member of the appellant, one Mr B D Webster ('Webster'), who had inserted the words 'Full and Final Settlement of Account' directly B below his signature on the front of the cheque. The respondent subsequently deposited the cheque, thereby accepting it in full and final settlement of its claim.

[6] The respondent's argument to the contrary was, in essence, that the forwarding of the cheque by the appellant to the C respondent did not constitute an offer of compromise by the appellant, in that the appellant did not seriously intend that it be regarded as such. Alternatively, even if the appellant had thus intended, the deposit of the cheque by the respondent did not constitute an acceptance of such offer.

[7] Much of the evidence presented to the trial Court turned upon certain correspondence between the parties. The cheque in question D was, in fact, accompanied by two letters, both of which were dated 19 February 2002 and were sent by Webster, on behalf of the appellant, to the respondent.

[8] The first letter related to a 'credit request' of E R122 649,18 arising from the sale of 'rejects' to Adidas at half-price and from the cost of 're-examining' and repairing faulty garments. In this regard the letter stated that the majority of the 'rejects' had a 'spirality' defect, while the repairs related to 'uneven hems' which were 'unpicked, trimmed straight and re-hemmed'. F

[9] The second letter related to a 'final reconciliation' with reference to the calculation of the balance of R229 846,07 claimed by the respondent. From this amount the credit request of R122 649,18 was deducted, leaving a final balance, according to the appellant, of R107 196,89. This was then the amount of the cheque paid by the G appellant to the respondent in 'full and final settlement of account'.

[10] The respondent rejected the appellant's credit request and reconciliation in a letter, dated 1 March 2002, from its attorneys to the appellant, the body of which reads as follows: H

'We address this letter to you on behalf of our client who has approached us for advice and attention herein. Our instructions are to place the following facts on record:

1.

Our client sold garments to yourselves of which the total amount due and owing amounts to R229 846,07. I

2.

On 19 February 2002 our client received a letter requesting a credit request with which our client disagrees and places in dispute.

3.

On 28 February 2002 our client received a cheque from yourselves in favour of our client in the amount of R107 196,89, furthermore with the wording thereon "in full and final settlement of the account".

Our instructions now are to inform you as follows:

J

2006 (6) SA p383

Van Zyl J

1.

Our client does not accept this payment...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex
4 practice notes
6 cases
  • Road Accident Fund v Krawa
    • South Africa
    • 20 Octubre 2011
    ...v Biddulph 1976 (1) SA 725 (A): dictum at 735A – H applied Be Bop A Lula Manufacturing & Printing CC v Kingtex Marketing (Pty) Ltd B 2006 (6) SA 379 (C): dictum in para [24] applied Boompret Investments (Pty) Ltd and Another v Paardekraal Concession Store (Pty) Ltd 1990 (1) SA 347 (A): refe......
  • BE Bop a Lula Manufacturing & Printing CC v Kingtex Marketing (Pty) Ltd
    • South Africa
    • 29 Noviembre 2007
    ...[14] at 334B - C.) Appeal upheld. The decision of Van Zyl J in Be Bop a Lula Manufacturing & Printing CC v Kingtex Marketing (Pty) Ltd 2006 (6) SA 379 (C) set aside. J 2008 (3) SA p328 Cases Considered Annotations A Reported cases Absa Bank Ltd v Van de Vyver NO 2002 (4) SA 397 (SCA): dicta......
  • Pillay v MEC for Education, KwaZulu-Natal, and Others
    • South Africa
    • 5 Julio 2006
    ...or the smooth running of the school or her daughter's performance as a learner. There is no evidence to contradict these assertions. J 2006 (6) SA p379 [68] The indirect discrimination, on the evidence, is not capable of objective substantiation in terms of criteria intrinsic to A the educa......
  • BE Bop a Lula Manufacturing & Printing CC v Kingtex Marketing (Pty) Ltd
    • South Africa
    • Supreme Court of Appeal
    • 29 Noviembre 2007
    ...Town; Schoeman Maree G Attorneys, Bloemfontein [1] Reported as Be Bop a Lula Manufacturing & Printing CC v Kingtex Marketing (Pty) Ltd 2006 (6) SA 379 (C). [2] Paragraph 46 (para 47 of the reported [3] Absa Bank Ltd v Van de Vyver NO 2002 (4) SA 397 (SCA) para 17. [4] DT Zeffertt 'Payments ......
  • Get Started for Free